
DC MAN DIES AFTER MEDICS
DIAGNOSE ACID-REFLUX
A 39-year-old Northeast Washington man died yesterday, a few hours after paramedics responding to his complaints of chest pains and trouble breathing told him he had acid reflux and did not take him to a hospital, family members said.
D.C. fire officials are investigating the circumstances surrounding the death of Edward L. Givens, who was found by family members just before 6 a.m. in his home in the 700 block of Division Avenue. Paramedics told Givens late Tuesday that he had acid reflux, instructed him to take Pepto-Bismol and left, family members said. LINK
“I don’t understand the paramedics, why, when he said he was in chest discomfort, he wasn’t taken to the hospital,” said Lolitha Givens, the man’s mother, who lives in the home and was there when 911 was called Tuesday night. “I’m just baffled by that.”
Well, let me say this about that: LINK
This is why we take EVERY single person who calls 911 to the E.R. This is also why EMS is so incredibly expensive. This case sums it up perfectly. In Philly, we will respond to close to 300,000 emergency calls a year. The vast majority are EMS, and most of them don’t require serious medical attention from emergency services (meaning that you are in imminent threat of death without life saving treatment).
However, there are many, many cases where people are pretty sick and we take them right to the E.R. Most of the time everything works out fine. They are the other 299,999 cases you will never hear about. Our department is so paranoid about cases like this that they have basically mandated a free ride to the hospital for whoever calls, whenever they call.
HOWEVER, there are times when the system breaks down. Usually it’s not the fault of the members. We are critically understaffed and there are far too many calls coming in. Plus, the system is deluged with abuse. Unfortunately that doesn’t appear to be the case here. Now I don’t know what D.C.’s protocols are, so I won’t speculate on what those guys should or should not have done – BUT in Philly we take EVERYONE, plain and simple. It’s actually easier that way. We would NEVER make a diagnosis. If anyone has chest pains or difficulty breathing, that’s an automatic ride to the E.R.
But therein lies the problem. We don’t have enough ambulances or Paramedics to taxi one thousand people a day…EVERY day of the year, to and from the hospital without being periodically overwhelmed. The fact of the matter is the EMS concept is supposed to be geared to traumatic emergencies, not routine health care. We have gotten away from what we are good at in many cases. I am much better at cutting you out of your wrecked car than I am at treating your abdominal pains.But since the Politicians demand we take everyone, that’s what we have to do. Once again, government is the problem, not the solution.
So I suspect these guys are in some serious trouble, barring any gross misrepresentation of the basic facts as reported. I wish them the best for “There but for the grace of God go I.”
Unfortunately, until politicians get serious about public safety and stop interfering, people who shouldn’t otherwise, will continue to die.